Which business has more tarmac-specific reviews?

BJ Surfacing does. Its 148 reviews include direct mentions of tarmac layers and resin surfacing, giving more tarmac-specific evidence than B E Rudman's 32 reviews.

Which is faster for a straightforward driveway resurfacing job?

BJ Surfacing is praised for quick, efficient execution, while B E Rudman works to a consistent four-week turnaround.

Who handles complex groundwork better alongside tarmac?

B E Rudman's track record leans toward managing dropped kerbs, drainage, and mixed materials as part of the same job.

BJ Surfacing vs B E Rudman: which one for tarmac and asphalt work?

Updated 2026-07-21 · 1,065 reviewed · 35 listed · How we rank ›

Both firms are genuine options for tarmac and asphalt surfacing in Cheltenham, with strong reputations built on driveway and patio work. This comparison weighs their review volume, tarmac-specific track record, and working style against each other, using our methodology to frame what actually matters for this job.

The differences that matter

Tarmac-specific track record. BJ Surfacing's reviews call out tarmac layers and resin surfaces by name, while B E Rudman's praise centres more on driveways, patios, and drainage generally.
Review volume and confidence. BJ Surfacing has 148 reviews against B E Rudman's 32, giving more data points specifically covering tarmac jobs.
Speed vs scheduling certainty. BJ Surfacing is praised for quick, efficient turnaround, whereas B E Rudman offers a defined four-week turnaround that suits planning ahead.
Composite score gap. BJ Surfacing scores 87.7 overall against B E Rudman's 79.1, driven largely by review volume rather than a sentiment gap.

Side by side

Criterion	BJ Surfacing	B E Rudman
Google rating	4.8 (148 reviews)	4.9 (32 reviews)
Services	natural stone paving, commercial paving, block paving, driveway paving	natural stone paving, commercial paving, block paving, driveway paving
Best for	Tarmac driveways, resin surfaces, and block paving where speed and a polished finish matter	Complex groundworks involving drainage and mixed materials alongside tarmac
Owner involvement	Will (owner) communicates directly at every stage	Ben leads jobs with James handling site leadership on some crews
Verification	Google-verified	Google-verified
Composite score	88	79

Google rating: BJ Surfacing: 4.8 (148 reviews); B E Rudman: 4.9 (32 reviews)
Services: BJ Surfacing: natural stone paving, commercial paving, block paving, driveway paving; B E Rudman: natural stone paving, commercial paving, block paving, driveway paving
Best for: BJ Surfacing: Tarmac driveways, resin surfaces, and block paving where speed and a polished finish matter; B E Rudman: Complex groundworks involving drainage and mixed materials alongside tarmac
Owner involvement: BJ Surfacing: Will (owner) communicates directly at every stage; B E Rudman: Ben leads jobs with James handling site leadership on some crews
Verification: BJ Surfacing: Google-verified; B E Rudman: Google-verified
Composite score: BJ Surfacing: 88; B E Rudman: 79

What reviewers say

BJ Surfacing

Work consistently exceeds expectations. Reviewers praise swift execution, attention to detail, and friendly professionalism. The team arrives on time, completes jobs efficiently, and leaves sites spotless. Will (the owner) communicates at every stage and handles complications proactively.

Across driveways, patios, and dropped kerbs, finishes are polished and durable. Resin surfaces, tarmac layers, and block paving transformations draw particular praise. The crew works in difficult weather, respects neighbours, and handles groundwork and aftercare with equal care.

B E Rudman

Ben and his team deliver consistent results across driveways, patios, and garden work. Reviewers praise their punctuality, skill, and attention to keeping sites clean daily. They manage complex jobs (dropped kerbs, drainage, mixed materials) with clear upfront guidance and complete on schedule.

The crew communicate daily updates and work in all conditions without cutting corners. Multiple reviewers return for follow-up work or refer friends and family. Named staff including James earn specific mention for site leadership and friendly professionalism.

Which should you pick?

Pick BJ Surfacing if

You want a contractor with a specific, proven history of tarmac and resin surfacing work
You value fast turnaround and direct owner communication throughout the job
You want the reassurance of a much larger review base backing up the tarmac work

Pick B E Rudman if

Your job mixes tarmac with drainage or dropped kerbs and needs coordinated groundwork
You prefer a fixed, predictable timeline like a four-week schedule
You want a contractor with two decades of operating history behind the crew

Verdict

For a straightforward tarmac or asphalt job, BJ Surfacing is the stronger fit: its reviews specifically mention tarmac layers and resin finishes, and it has far more data behind that reputation. B E Rudman earns its place when the tarmac work is part of a bigger groundworks job involving drainage or dropped kerbs, where its logistics experience and steady four-week schedule count for more than raw review volume.

Need help choosing the right contractor?

Describe your project and get quotes from suitable paving contractor in Cheltenham.

When you submit an enquiry through this site's forms, we may pass it to partner providers who can do the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based solely on our published method and are never influenced by referral fees.

FAQ

Which business has more tarmac-specific reviews?: BJ Surfacing does. Its 148 reviews include direct mentions of tarmac layers and resin surfacing, giving more tarmac-specific evidence than B E Rudman's 32 reviews.
Which is faster for a straightforward driveway resurfacing job?: BJ Surfacing is praised for quick, efficient execution, while B E Rudman works to a consistent four-week turnaround.
Who handles complex groundwork better alongside tarmac?: B E Rudman's track record leans toward managing dropped kerbs, drainage, and mixed materials as part of the same job.